Everyone I know personally thinks this is complete nonsense and rubbish, and hates it.
Then Stardock tosses in an arbitrary -3 diplo penalty for leaving UP.
Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
"Fun!".
We're all demanding direct democracy IRL, at least here in Canada, but in our games, we're going backwards, in the future, no less.
In Canada, its called the "First Past the Post" system, by the way, feel free to look up one of the many, many articles castigating it as undemocratic, broken, corrupt, subject to rampant abuse, and an archaic impediment to progress.