I would prefer to see Sins without cloaking. Cloaking is good for games where micromanagement is key, and I admit that you still have to micro in Sins (but rarely, especially with capital ships, in my week of playing the game). Also, I don't want to have to purchase a special detector unit in order to see a swarm of cloaked little ships that are chipping away at my flagship. You may be invisible, but you still emit infrared radiation. Considering that the Sins universe is ahead of our time, they should be able to use infrared cameras, but I don't know if that is affected by the cold of space. Oops, rant.
Anyways, if cloaking is to be implemented, I say that it should only apply to scouts, and that they wont be able to attack while cloaked. Yeah. A more pressing matter to me is space elves, not cloaking ( I despise them).