It's worth mentioning that I've seen this sentiment echoed on numerous gaming forums over the net. Many people have repeatedly reacted very favorably to Stardock and now Ironclad for taking this stance.
I don't know how badly, if at all, piracy impacted GalCiv2 sales more or less than other PC games, or how its impacting Sins, but I do know that the goodwill you're building is an asset that few other gaming companies have.
Well, i can say that any game you can think of i can find on the internet to download, no matter what copy protection it came with. And also say that if it was not for being able to try this game first i would have never bought it.
Its hard to 'return' a pc game, more or less impossible in most all cases. Expecting people to buy something just because a review website said it was good is silly.
The only form of 'copy protection' that has EVER worked is CD keys for online services such as multiplayer things. That works, thats a good idea, it doesn't screw anything up.
But there are several games i own that have various copy protection on them that screw with my PC (starforce anyone?), so what do i play on? A cracked version=p
I get the feeling sometimes that the only reason we see copy protection is because developers know their games are trash and want to try and sell boxes on hype before the crack comes out and people realize how bad the games are.
I also have to say that you need to sell more than just the game in order to sell things well. I remember years ago i was walking down the isle at target, and i saw a box for a computer game. It had a big nifty emblem on the front and said "STARSIEGE". I picked it up and boy was it heavy! I shook it around some and it sounded like there was a lot to it, more than just the game itself on a disk. I looked at the pictures and figured that was pretty awesome looking. With out knowing anything else about it i bought it. It just felt like it had 'quality' seeping out of the box.
So far, with this game and also galciv2, stardock has managed to project a 'completeness', like im getting something more than just a bunch of code and a piece of plastic.
I will say its kind of disappointing that the collectors box lists a hotkey card and a tech tree as part of the 'bonus'=P Those things should come standard, shouldnt they? Then again the retail box is cheaper than most games, so i suppose its forgiven=p